Peak Dog vs. Degenerate Dog?

This is Balto, the famous Siberian Husky sled dog who led his team on the final leg of the 1925 serum run to Nome, Alaska. The windchill of the whiteout blizzard when Balto set out was −70 °F. The team traveled all night, with almost no visibility, over the 600-foot Topkok Mountain, and reached Nome at 5:30 AM.

Balto is not the only dog who deserves credit–Togo took a longer and even more dangerous stretch of the run.

And this is a modern Siberian Husky:

Now, don’t get me wrong. He’s a beautiful dog. But he’s a very different dog. I think he’s trying to turn into a German Shepherd-wolf hybrid. Balto practically looks like a corgi next to him.

Siberian huskies were bred by people who depended on them for their lives, and had to endure some of nature’s very harshest weather. We moderns, by contrast, like to keep our dogs inside our warm, comfortable houses to play with our kids or guard our stuff. Have modern huskies been bred for looks rather than sled-pulling?

On the other hand, winning times for the Iditarod have dropped from 20 days to just 8 since the race began in the 1970s, so clearly there are some very fast huskies out there.


19 thoughts on “Peak Dog vs. Degenerate Dog?

  1. Modern Siberian huskies have a body shape more like Fritz than Balto.

    Also, modern Iditarod teams are almost made of Alaskan huskies instead of Siberian huskies. Alaskan huskies are a fairly new breed developed for speed, toughness, and intelligence in cold conditions. The base stock is Siberian husky, but there is a lot of admixture from shepards, running hounds, and native Eskimo dogs.


  2. I would not be surprised if someone made the case that the Siberian husky looks similar to the German Shepherd for reasons of convergent selection – Siberian huskies being the Soviet dog of choice for guarding gulags and taking down escaping prisoners. (I’m not claiming huskies were used as guard dogs; I’m saying that as a causal role in a plausible explanation that makes sense. Someone would have to check.)


  3. If you want an appex-dog, look no further than the Saluki.
    But modern breeds are abominations indeed, just look at the English Bulldog.


  4. My favorite dog I ever had.

    Such a great dog. She died unfortunately. Not noisy like a lot of lap dogs. She would bark but not incessantly. Loved to sit in your lap and hang out.

    Think of all the breeds that have died out. One that interest me is the war dogs of the Cimmerians. A tribe of giants the Romans fought. They finally defeated them by thrusting spears into their eyes while another soldier cut at their legs. After they were defeated they said it took three days to fight off their war dogs. Possibly they were the predecessors of these dogs.

    “…The Spanish conquistadors used armored dogs that had been trained to kill natives….”

    There’s a guy who writes about violence. James LaFond, who says that the Spanish war dogs were the major factor in defeating the Native Americans. Armored dogs that tore people to pieces. Very frightening.


    • Well, I think the diseases that killed something like 90% of the Native Americans were probably a bigger deal than the dogs, but dogs can certainly be tough.
      Papillons are cute little dogs–little dogs seem underrated. Too many people in my neighborhood have big golden retrievers or labs because they’re supposed to be “good with kids” but IMO they’re much too big for the houses/yards.


      • “…I think the diseases that killed something like 90% of the Native Americans were probably a bigger deal than the dog…”

        You are of course correct. I should have been more specific. The war dogs impressed, violently, the power of the Europeans of the first tribes they met when relations between them became violent. The tribes were basically slaves of the Aztecs and when Hernán Cortés his horses, war dogs and armor whipped the first tribes they threw in with Cortés as the had no love for the Aztecs who were cutting the hearts out of their children in their temples. So in the first shock attacks by Europeans diseases were not the deciding factor. Later, yes very much so.

        A good book to read on the subjection of the Americas is, “Hernando De Soto, A Savage Quest in the Americas”. These Spanish Conquistadors were savage, vile, evil but either very, very brave or very, very stupid or psychopaths. The risk they took were astonishing. It’s amazing that they weren’t killed to the last Man.


  5. There is confirmation breeding…. making sure the dogs confirm to a set of observable physical standards like the akc, ukc etc telling a folks dog should be this tall, weigh this much, be these colors etc etc

    And there is type breeding. When you breed a dog for a type of attributes and or attitudes.

    Working dogs vs show dogs basically. The working dogs used to bring in ducks, pull a sled or chase down felons don’t much look like the bright shinny dogs you see in books or at dog shows.

    Personally I think type breeding is better for the dogs. Less health problems, better mental and emotional health and what not plus you are keeping the traditions of that breed alive. For type bred dogs I don’t think there has been much in the way of changes. My bull dogs look like the dogs in the drawings of bull fighting dogs from 150-200 years ago but there is a huge difference between a working German Shepherd and one breed for show

    I love dogs but I think my Great Danes where the best over all family dogs. Easy to train, they loved kids and where good with them yet big enough to scare the shit out of anyone with bad intent. One of the Danes I rescued crushed and damn near severed a man’s hand with one bite. 150 pounds of pissed off dog is a wrecking ball. My bull dogs are way to active and knock my kids down all the time. They dont miss nap time though. If Ton Spawn or Half Ton or one of the grandkids is sleeping it’s a good bet one of my bull dogs is sleeping with them. I also have two Persa Canario’s who are very protective of my younger children but they are extremely aggressive toward strangers and not a good dog for most families

    I love dogs, they have always been a joy in my life but all around apex dog for me is a type bred “pit bull”. My bull dogs can do pretty much whatever I need them to do. Chase live stock, walk all day, chase off alligators, stay alert all night, run rabbits, hold pigs etc etc. Lots of dogs do certain tasks better but I am pretty sure no other breed can do as so many jobs so well


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s