Graph of energy input vs. output by economic type.

energyvsorganizationI have been looking for this graph for some time, failed, and finally re-created it from memory. So warning: this was re-created from memory. A really old memory.

Anyway, this graph shows the relationship between energy inputs (work) and energy output (typically food, but also shelter, children, luxury goods, etc.) for a given variety of human technology/economic organizational structure.

(Note that the graph is not to scale and only a conceptual representation of the idea.)

So for example, in a hunter gathering society, inputing more energy by hunting more often will reward people with more food, but only up to a point. As game becomes scarcer, hunters bring home less food, and eventually you eat all of the animals in the area and are actually getting less out of hunting than you’re putting into it.

Even at its maximum efficiency, a hunter-gatherer society simply can’t (in most environments) obtain much food and can’t support many people.

Growing food takes much more energy, but the results support far more people.

Modern industrial societies take a ton of energy to run, but also support billions of people, cities, etc.

Of course, even modern industrial societies still need to be careful about that right-hand side of the curve.

8 thoughts on “Graph of energy input vs. output by economic type.

  1. We’re missing pastoralists? My impression was that their curve wasn’t as steep as farmers, but that high protein translated to better calories / stronger and healthier people.


  2. Is this intended to be “energy input” or “energy input per capita”? I.e., I’m thinking if it’s not per capita then the low-tech curves are basically equivalent to population size/desnity


    • Eh let’s go with per capita. Abstractly I don’t think it has to be; a steam engine gets more energy out than a wood fire no matter how many people there are, but as a practical matter you can’t really separate humans from the equation. I’m really tired today, though, so I may just be muddled.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s